I am only going to review the Lord of the Rings and general site sections, as my site is for LotR only, but this won't affect your content score because it is based on everything :) Hope you understand.
>> Main page
You have a wonderful layout! The colours are very Christmassy and warm. The layout is easy to navigate :)
>> Middle-earth section
>> Adoptables
These are so sweet! Perhaps say what you used to make them with? The code idea is great too :)
>> Banners
Very organized! I like how you've separated it into characters. They're all wonderful!
>> Blinkies
You have some original ideas
>> Backgrounds
I like the ones you have so far :) Why not say they are for use on websites because you also have wallpapers?
>> Wallpapers
These are brilliant, especially the Frodo and Sam one! :)
>> Avatars
It's good that you have these separated into stills and animated. But you seem to have 2 links to the first page of stills. I love the awards one :)
>> Games
Visitor interaction, and great fun! The love calculator is great!
>> Fan Section
Another good way to get visitors to interact... but remember, write out your email!
>> About Me
You have a great taste in music! ;) Warn that your LiveJournal is a new window
>> Past Layouts
Maybe make the previewsopen in a new window? Any the third layout doesn't load properly....
>> FAQs
Write out your email
>> Affiliates
Very organized, but again, write out your email
>> Link Me
Maybe make some 50x50 codes? More people are using them now.
>> Contact
Yey! You wrote out your email :)
>>To do:
Write out email
>> Score
Layout - 4/5
Originality - 3/5
Content - 15/20
Navigation - 9/10
Graphics/Appearence - 8/10
>> Total - 39/50
>> Overall - Wonderful site, with lots of brilliant graphics!